Demosthenes 'I have
always made common cause with the people' (330
BC) The speech delivered by the
Athenian statesman Demosthenes (384-384 BC)
at his trial is considered the greatest speech of the
ancient world's greatest orator. By modern standards it
is long and often obscure; its greatness, moreover, is
difficult to capture in translation, even in this early
nineteenth century version by Henry Lord Brougham, the
eminent British politician and social reformer.
From 351 BC, Demosthenes led the
desperate struggle of the Athenians to maintain the
freedom of the city states against the imperialist
ambitions of Philip of Macedon. His speeches denouncing
Philip - the Philippics - incited the Athenians
to war, but resulted in the defeat of Chaeronia in 338
and the establishment of Macedonian supremacy.
A proposal to award Demosthenes a loser's crown
was opposed by Aeschines, who had negotiated the peace
with Philip. At his trial Aeschines set out to destroy
Demosthenes, whose courage is demonstrated in his
speech. He turns the attack on Aeschines, assesses his
career, dares to state unpopular truths, and demolishes
his opponent.
It was my lot, Aeschines, when a boy, to frequent the
schools suited to my station, and to have wherewithal to
avoid doing anything mean through want. When I emerged
from boyhood, I did as was consistent with my origin;
filled the office of Choregus, furnished galleys,
contributed to the revenue, and was wanting in no acts
of munificence, public or private, but ready to aid both
my country and my friends. When I entered into public
life, I deemed it proper to choose the course which led
to my being repeatedly crowned both by this country and
the other Greek states, so that not even you, my
enemies, will now venture to pronounce the part I took
other than honourable. Such then were my fortunes...
But you, venerable man, who look down upon others,
see what kind of fortunes were yours compared with mine!
Brought up from your boyhood in abject poverty, you both
were helper in your father's school, and you ground the
ink, sponged the forms, and swept the room, doing the
work of a household slave, not of a freeborn youth. When
grown up, you recited your mother's books as she
performed her mysteries, and you helped in her other
trickeries. At night, dressed like a bacchanal, and
draining the goblet, and purifying the initiated, and
rubbing them with clay and with bran, rising from the
lustration, you ordered them to cry, 'I've fled the
evil; I've found the good'; bragging that none ever
roared so loud before; and truly I believe it; for do
not doubt that he who now speaks out so lustily, did not
then howl most splendidly...
I come to the charges that apply to your life and
conversation. You chose that line of policy (ever since
the plan struck your mind) by which, as long as the
country flourished, you led the life of the hare,
frightened, and trembling, and perpetually expecting the
scourge for the offences of which you were conscious;
but when all others were suffering, you were seen in
high spirits by all. But he who was so cheerful after
the death of thousands of his fellow-citizens, what does
he deserve to suffer at the hands of the survivors?...
Draw then the parallel between your life and mine,
Aeschines, quietly and not acrimoniously; and demand of
this audience which of the two each of them had rather
choose for his own. You were an usher - I a scholar; you
were an initiator - I was initiated; you danced at the
games - I presided over them; you were a clerk of the
Assembly, I a member; you, a third-rate actor, I a
spectator; you were constantly breaking down - I always
hissing you; your measures were all in the enemy's
favour -mine always in the country's; and, in a word,
now on this day the question as to me is whether or not
I shall be crowned, while nothing whatever is alleged
against my integrity; while it is your lot to appear
already as a calumniator, and the choice of evils before
you is that of still continuing your trade, or being put
to silence by failing to obtain a fifth of the votes...
Among all other men I observe these principles and
these distinctions to prevail. Does any one wilfully do
wrong? He is the object of indignation and of
punishment. Does any one commit an error
unintentionally? He is pardoned, not punished. Has one
who neither does any wrong nor commits any error devoted
himself to a course which to all appeared expedient, and
has he been in common with all disappointed of success?
It is not fair to reprobate or to attack him, but to
condole with him. All this is established not only in
all our jurisprudence, but by Nature herself in her
unwritten laws, and in the very constitution of the
human mind. Thus has Aeschines so far surpassed all
other men in cruelty and calumny, that those same things
which he enumerates as misfortunes he also imputes to me
as crimes...
In what circumstances then ought a statesman and an
orator to be vehement? When the State is in jeopardy
upon the ruin of affairs - when the people are in
conflict with the enemy - then it is that the strenuous
and patriotic citizen appears. But when Aeschines cannot
pretend to have any ground whatever for even charging me
with any offence in public life, or, I will add, in
private, either in the name of the country or his own -
for him to come forward with a vamped up attack on my
crowning and my honours, and to waste so many words upon
this subject, is the working of personal spite and envy,
and a little mind, and shows no good man.
To me, indeed, Aeschines, it appears from these
speeches of yours, as if you had instituted this
impeachment through a desire of making a display of
vociferation, not of punishing any one's misconduct. For
it is not the speech of the orator, Aeschines, that
avails, nor yet the compass of his voice, but his
feeling in unison with the community and bearing enmity
or affection towards them whom his country loves or
hates. He that thus possesses his soul speaks ever with
right feeling. But he that bows to those from whom the
country has danger to apprehend, does not anchor in the
same roadstead with the people; accordingly he does not
look for safety from the same quarter. But mark me, I
do: for I have always made common cause with the people,
nor have I ever taken any course for my peculiar and
individual interest. Can you say as much?
Then how? - You, who, instantly after the battle,
went on the embassy to Philip, the cause of all that in
these times befell your country; and that after refusing
the office at all former periods, as every one knows? -
But who deceives the country? Is it not he that says one
thing and thinks another? And who is he upon whom at
every assembly solemn execration is proclaimed? Is it
not such a man as this? What worse charge can any one
bring against an orator than that his words and his
sentiments do not tally? Yet you have been discovered to
be such a man; and you still lift your voice and dare to
look this assembly in the face!...
What alliance ever accrued to the country of your
making? Or what succours, or goodwill, or glory of your
gaining? Or what embassy, or what other public
functions, whereby the state acquired honour? What
domestic affair, or concern of the Greek states, or of
strangers, over which you presided, was ever set right
through you? What galleys, what armaments, what
arsenals, what repairs of the walls, what cavalry? In
what one of all these particulars have you ever proved
useful? What benefit has ever accrued to either rich or
poor from your fortunes?
None. - 'But, hark!' says some one, 'if nothing of
all this was done, at least there existed good
dispositions and public spirit.' Where? When? you most
wicked of men? - Your contributing nothing was not owing
to your poverty but to your taking special care nothing
you did should ever counteract the schemes of those to
whom all your policy was subservient. In what, then, are
you bold, and when are you munificent? When any thing is
to be urged against your countrymen, then are you most
copious of speech - most profuse of money - most rich in
memory - a first-rate actor - the Theocrines of the
stage!...
Two qualities, men of Athens, every citizen of
ordinary worth ought to possess (I shall be able in
general terms to speak of myself in the least invidious
manner): he should both maintain in office the purpose
of a firm mind and the course suited to his country's
pre-eminence, and on all occasions and in all his
actions the spirit of patriotism. This belongs to our
nature; victory and might are under the dominion of
another power. These dispositions you will find to have
been absolutely inherent in me. For observe; neither
when my head was demanded, nor when they dragged me
before the Amphyctions, nor when they threatened, nor
when they promised, nor when they let loose on me these
wretches like wild beasts, did I ever abate in any
particular my affection for you.
This straightforward and honest path of policy, from
the very first, I chose; the honour, the power, the
glory of my country to promote -these to augment - in
these to have my being. Never was I seen going about the
streets elated and exulting when the enemy was
victorious, stretching out my hand, and congratulating
such as I thought would tell it elsewhere, but hearing
with alarm any success of our own armies, moaning and
bent to the earth like these impious men, who rail at
this country as if they could do so without also
stigmatizing themselves; and who, turning their eyes
abroad, and seeing the prosperity of the enemy in the
calamities of Greece, rejoice in them, and maintain that
we should labour to make them last for ever!
Let not, oh gracious God, let not such conduct
receive any manner of sanction from thee! Rather plant
even in these men a better spirit and better feelings!
But if they are wholly incurable, then pursue
themselves, yea, themselves by themselves, to utter and
untimely perdition by land and by sea; and to us who are
spared vouchsafe to grant the speediest rescue from our
impending alarms, and an unshaken security! |