Sophie on Romanticism (pp. 342-359)
Sophie's World (Gaarder) The Romantic Era began toward the end of the eighteenth century and
lasted until the middle of the nineteenth century. It started in Germany
as a reaction to the Enlightenment's unequivocal emphasis on reason. The
new catchwords were 'feeling', 'imagination', and 'yearning'.
Many of the Romantics saw themselves as the German philosopher Kant's successors. Kant had
established that there was a limit to what we can know about 'things in themselves': we can only know the world through
sense impressions, but those impressions are shaped by the attributes of
our minds. So, our minds limit our understanding of reality. Even so,
through exercise of the imagination we are brought closer to an
experience of 'the thing in itself'.
The Romantics who followed Kant emphasized the importance of
the individual's contribution to knowledge. They glorified the artist's
unique interpretation of life. By abandoning ourselves to the aesthetic
experience of an art work of genius, we push beyond the limited realm of
logic and move closer to 'the inexpressible'. In his transports of artistic
rapture, the poet, musician or painter could sense the dissolving
boundary between dream and reality.
Coleridge said,
What if you slept? And what if, in your sleep,
you dreamed? And what if, in your dream, you went to heaven and
there plucked a strange and beautiful flower? And what if, when
you awoke, you had the flower in your hand? Ah, what then? |
The yearning for the distant and unattainable was characteristic of
the Romantics. They longed for bygone eras such as the Middle Ages, and
they longed for distant cultures like the Orient with its mysticism.
They were drawn to night, to twilight, to old ruins and the
supernatural.
The Romantics believed that all of nature, both the human soul and
physical reality, is the expression of one Absolute or World Spirit. In
this sense we can see the influence of neo-Platonic thought on their
understanding of the universe. However, Nature was also thought of as an
organism, a living being constantly developing its own innate
potentialities. Aristotle had said much the same thing: substance
strives to achieve a potential form, and the universe itself is evolving
towards a final form.
Another German philosopher, Johann Gottfried von Herder
(1744-1803), developed this dynamic notion of the universe's substance by asserting that
history itself is characterized by evolution and design. He believed
that history was divided into particular epochs and each has its own
leading ideas and intrinsic values. He also believed that each nation
has its own character or 'soul' determined by its unique folk culture,
language and history. A nation's people are understood as one collective organism unfolding its
own innate potentiality. Herder encouraged the collection of folk songs and
folk tales, calling them Voices of the People. The Brothers Grimm
made a famous collection of old German fairy tales: "Snow White and
the Seven Dwarfs", "Rumpelstiltskin". "Hansel and
Gretel", and "The Frog Prince", among many others. The
fairy tale genre was passionately cultivated by the Romantics. One of
the German masters of the genre was E.T.A. Hoffman.
Immanuel Kant (1724-1804)
Sophie's World (Gaarder), pp. 322-341 KantRescuing the Scientific Method by Affirming the Primacy of our
Subjectivity
Rescuing Free Will in a World Determined by Cause and Effect
Kant was another great synthesizer in the history of philosophy who
melded the rationalism of Descartes with the empiricism of Locke:
- rationalists: the basis for human knowledge is in the mind
- empiricists: all knowledge of the world proceeds from the
senses
Kant believed that both sensation and reason contribute to our
conception of the world:
- All knowledge comes from sensation, but those
sensations are filtered and altered by the conditions of the
mind. Furthermore, it is the attributes of reason which create
the human conception of reality. (Compare to seeing the world
through a pair of red sun glasses. Or compare to the shape water
takes when it is poured into a pitcher.)
- So, Time and Space become physical entities through human
modes of perception. The law of causality belongs to the human
mind. Our innate perception of the world demands cause and
effect. This mode of perception shapes our understanding of the
material substance of reality. (In this way Kant rebuts
Hume's radical empiricism: his belief that cause and effect
cannot be proven as a law.)
- Compare the different responses a cat and a human would
have to a ball rolled by them. The cat would chase the ball; the
human would look to see who had rolled the ball.
However, Kant also believed that the apparatus of reason prevents us
from knowing the world in itself; we can only know how the world appears
to us.
- the thing in itself: the substance of the
material world
- the thing for me: how the material world appears to me die to
the forms of knowledge
Kant argued that it was impossible to prove the existence of God
either through reason (Descartes) or experience (Aristotle). However, he
insisted that the existence of a soul, of God, and of human free will
was a moral necessity. Therefore, for these practical reasons we must
possess an innate ability to distinguish right from wrong in the same
way that we perceive phenomena as linked in a causal sequence. For Kant
moral sense precedes experience-- it applies to all people at all times.
Kant also believed that only through moral action do we act freely.
The conditions of the environment and the specificity of the apparatus
(physical and mental) with which we are born determine our behavior.
Only by engaging in difficult moral decisions can we achieve freedom and
actually participate in the world as it is beyond our sensory
perception.
- The Categorical Imperative: "Act as if the
maxim of your action were to become a Universal Law of
Nature." (Or, cut the cake, and let the other choose which
piece too eat first.)
- "Treat others not only as a means but as an end."
- Hegel rejected Kant's idea that the material world, "the
thing in itself" was beyond the human ability to directly perceive.
Even so, he asserted that the truth is subjective and changes from
generation to generation. He believed that there are no eternal
truths.
- Hegel believed the truth to be inherent in an evolving "world
spirit" which is the sum of human utterances, thought and
culture.
- Only through studying the history of ideas can we gain
insight into the way the world spirit is evolving and the forms it
has taken in different ages.
- Human actions can only be deemed to be right or wrong in relation
to their historical context. (ex slavery)
- Progress: Reason is progressive: the world spirit is
developing towards 'consciousness of itself': a state of greater
rationality and human freedom. The world spirit has passed through
two phases (the subjective and the objective) and it will culminate
in a third phase (the absolute).
- The Dialectic: the history of ideas progresses
through conflict: a thought generates its opposite and then a third
thought creatively synthesizes the two.
- For example,
The Eleatics (material substance is
eternal). vs. |
Heraclitus (everything constantly changes) |
Empedocles synthesized both ideas in
his atomic theory. |
Descartes's rationalism |
Hume's empiricism |
Kant's synthesis of the two |
Being |
Nothingness |
Becoming |
|